A while ago, I wrote about a meal planner service called $5 Dinners that provided instructions on how to make 20 slow cooker meals for $150 at Costco. You go to Costco, buy exactly what is on the provided shopping list (6 pack of chicken breasts, 15 lb bag of potatoes, massive tub of BBQ sauce, etc), and then chop and separate all the ingredients into 20 separate freezer bags. When you want an easy dinner, pop a bag into your slow cooker in the morning and you’ll have dinner ready by the time you’re done with work.
I paid $5 for complete instructions including grocery shopping list, assembly videos, and label template files. The exact meal plan that I bought is now called Slow Cooker Freezer Packs, 1st Edition Complete. It took me a few months to get around to actually making all the meals, but I did make them all in November 2014. Here are some pictures of my final product:
Why did it take over a year to get this review out? Well, part of the reason is that it took us a year to actually finish all the meals! Unfortunately, the reason why it took us a year to finish the meals is… we didn’t enjoy the meals very much. I didn’t want to write a negative review for an entrepreneurial idea that I thought was really cool that was based on my own tastes, but they are doing quite well so allow me to use this as another opportunity to provide you helpful information based on my own failures. 🙂
Takeaways
- Cook and eat a sample recipe first before making 5 of the same recipe. I was distracted by my own excitement of being able to knock out 20 meals in one day, I just jumped straight in. I found the recipes to be a bit bland in flavor and boring in texture when followed exactly. You may feel differently, and their newer recipes could be much better, but again you won’t know until you try it.
- Set aside an entire afternoon. Making all 20 freezer packs in one day took about 4-5 hours, and it was pretty exhausting. Set aside plenty of time, as it takes a lot of chopping and portioning.
- Make sure you have adequate freezer space. Even if you follow their tips to lay them flat, these take up a lot of room! We have a standalone freezer and it was still a tight fit. You may also want to place them in a tub in case of leaks.
- Use the plans as a starting point for your own customizations. Adding your own herbs and spices, as well as some lemon juice or hot sauce at the end can really perk things up. Personally, I prefer to season and brown my meat before putting it into the slow cooker. I love me some Maillard reaction!
- Try using your own recipes first. A more gradual way to start your own “backup dinners” is to simply double-up on one of your current recipes, and freeze the extra portions.
- For the price of $5, I still think it is worth a shot. There may be different and/or improved recipes now. I still think it is a great entrepreneurial idea.
The Best Credit Card Bonus Offers – October 2024
Big List of Free Stocks from Brokerage Apps
Best Interest Rates on Cash - October 2024
Free Credit Scores x 3 + Free Credit Monitoring
Best No Fee 0% APR Balance Transfer Offers
Little-Known Cellular Data Plans That Can Save Big Money
How To Haggle Your Cable or Direct TV Bill
Big List of Free Consumer Data Reports (Credit, Rent, Work)
I remember you posting about this previously and my one reservation was “what if you don’t like the recipe?”
I also have found that, regardless of the recipe, slow cooker meals do tend to be bland and lack texture. That’s the trade-off. It does help a lot to brown the meat before starting it in the cooker (and almost all of America’s Test Kitchen’s slow cooker recipes include doing so), but if you do that you sacrifice a lot of the convenience of slow-cooking.
Yes! Exactly the same experience here. I believe I started to prep the meals around 7pm and didn’t finish until 2 or 3am (and had to be up at 7 for work) so I wasn’t very happy about that. My entire freezer space was taken. And then all the meals were either tasteless or downright disgusting to the point that a year later I still had at least a third of them sitting in the fridge…
I think doing an organized plan once is a great guide to then planning and doing it yourself. It was extremely efficient and some meals were great like the stew and taco soup, but some I would not make again like the curry. Many I would tweak and just freeze the vegetable/bean ingredients, keep the meat separate and cook them another way later while adding spices. That way when you end up on your third day of chicken, you can just thaw one bag and have a seemingly new meal. It was a lot of effort to shop and then cook in the same day. I split the effort with a friend and we were still exhausted. All in all it was a good learning lesson to remind me to plan meals ahead and that much can be frozen together which saves money in the long run. It was also great to have meals ready when others had an ill parent and I knew I could give them stew ready to go.
I would be a little concerned that the “5 Dollar Dinners” cost $7.50 each (20 meals for $150), but maybe that’s just me.